We do not dispute the confiscation of the binder including manufacturing information, so that item can certainly be removed from the request.
Reasoning for Return:
While I can appreciate both the timely approach and the perspectives about the potential usage of the materials listed, based on the crimes that Mr. Bastille has paid for both through fines and time in prison, potential usage in crime is not the same as usage in crime, bro. We've already omitted items that serve minimal purposes outside of commission of illegal activities from this request.
However, materials like metal, plastic, etc. are an essential part of the thriving economy of San Andreas, and also a key measure in reducing the chance of recidivism in reforming citizens such as Mr. Bastille. Given his commitment to turning over a new leaf, such materials would be used for repairs to vehicles, artistic endeavors, paying off his debts, home improvement projects, and much, much more.
Further punishing an individual for a crime they have not committed is contrary to the judicial process outside of Minority Report.
We appreciate the consideration of the court,
-Lyra (L-Y-R-A)
